PDA

View Full Version : Smokys TN, NC


Giantfish
11-02-2006, 03:15 PM
The smokys are in tennessee and north carolina. So I was wondering,( this is stupid) But is the fishing any better on the NC side? I have nevr fish over there and don't know a single stream. I know that the acid in the water changes.( I'v tested it.) This is one of my dumbest questions but I was just wondering. have any of you done better on one side than the other? I know some of you come from NC so tell me. Thanks.

Giantfish

DryFly1
11-02-2006, 03:46 PM
Giantfish,

Everyone knows that tennessee trout are the fearsist,fightenist, fish that ever swum a mountain stream!!! And I hear tell that those NC fish's DNA are altered so that those NC folk can have something to compete with! Ok, probably not entirely true but some of it has to be.


Actually, both sides have something very special in-store for the angler that searches out "the perfect spot". I find both sides offer unique opportunities!!

DryFly1

David Knapp
11-02-2006, 04:06 PM
In my opinion, each and every Smokies stream has its own personality and special tendencies. I go to different streams depending on what type of water I want to fish, what species I prefer to target, what methods I feel like using for the day, etc... I don't think that some streams are necessarily better or worse than others, just different...

Woody
11-02-2006, 05:13 PM
Tennessee of course, why go anywhere else. That is my personal opinon. I don't go over the mountain much anymore. I hear strange things happen to people over there. Be careful, don't go alone. Try not to spend the night. If you stay over there to long you may turn into an ACC fan. God help you.

doghaircaddis
11-02-2006, 05:26 PM
I rekin I like to fish up air on Rocky Top. If you aint fermilir thats on the Tennessee side.

Giantfish
11-02-2006, 05:52 PM
WoW! I love watching the NC and TN talk he he I made a TN,NC revolution keep going guys. WHICH SIDE IS BETTER! TN OR NC WHICH HAS BETTER FISH< TN OR NC. WHICH ARE BETTERFISHERMEN TN OR NC!!! ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
sorry ijust love to watch that stuff! keep going. ;D

Giantfish

David Knapp
11-02-2006, 06:49 PM
WHICH ARE BETTERFISHERMEN TN OR NC!!!

Why that should be obvious...us Tennessee folks win that one hands down!!! :P ::) ;D ;D

Giantfish
11-02-2006, 06:59 PM
This is a good debate. Now I'm adding Ohio! Are they better than TNor NC. I know their are Ohio guys out there

doghaircaddis
11-02-2006, 09:54 PM
Giantfish,

Man...you are like the energizer bunny. Did you get a chance to check-out any of those books that were recommended to you?

Giantfish
11-02-2006, 10:49 PM
I know I keep going and going! ;D sorry I just got real excited when everyone started saying who was better it was just fun :) No books yet but I have found them and coparring prices.I just love a good debate and I got a FF one going and that was cool!!!! ;D Plus I had alot of candy ;) I loved that debate and it doesen't have to end unless you guys want it to.

Giantfish

russ
11-03-2006, 12:00 PM
This is a good debate. Now I'm adding Ohio! Are they better than TNor NC. *I know their are Ohio guys out there

You can't lump in any yankees when you're comparing fisherman ::). Even NC fishermen beat those yankees! Ofcorse TN fishermen are better than NC. Asking if TN fishermen are better than NC fishermen is a goofy question; It's like asking if a boling ball is better than a gun for squirrel huntin. You just can't compare, they're not even in the same league with us TN boys. You must be a yankee. I bet you don't even eat cornbread all crushed up in your buttermilk do ya ;D ;)


Lets see what happens now ;D

Woody
11-03-2006, 12:09 PM
Tennessee, Everything is better in East TN. Period. End of discussion. If you do go over the mountain make sure you get all your vaccinations.

ruggerfly
11-03-2006, 01:07 PM
I went to college in TN, and I now live in AL (so I can be somewhat impartial). I personally like fishing anywhere in the Smoky Mtn NP, but my personal favorite creek is on the NC side.

Giantfish
11-03-2006, 02:48 PM
Yes, I do but my cornbread in buttermilk and from TN. Thats why I started this somehow!? It satrted with a simple question and now this I love it. Where are the Ohio guys at? come out if you can. ;D No offence it's just a friendly debate :)

Giantfish

lauxier
11-03-2006, 08:57 PM
I'm from Kentuky---Tennessee trout are **** to catch in the fall--they usually get off the hook--you know there is no catching them--too powerful--but---come wintertime--they are easy to catch--i use a hoop-wulf--a good fly---it wears them out--i do not eat them--i let them go---who wants to mess up next years fun--i have found north carolina trout over-rated--they are tough in the fall--they know every fly you cast to them---in the winter---they are uncatchable---too fast---too smart---too everything-----come March---their bio-systems and genes kick in ----you cannot catch them------you don't have to----they float up and surrender to you......

buckeyetrouter
11-04-2006, 09:24 AM
boy oh boy.......really trying to get it going.. ;)....well, I can't get any thing started because we are in the process of property searching in E. Tenn. and my daughter has already moved to E. Tenn....so in this case I will bide my time till I am a residant of Tenn and can jump on the TN side of this argument...uhhh,...debate. I can tell you that here in Ohio we have basically 2 (yes, only two) streams that we can trout fish so we end up fly fishing for every thing else just to work on our casting skills....does that make us deprived???? yes and no....you have to work a wide variety of waters and many different fish personalities to get something on the end of your leader. I do know this....untill you hook a 10lb carp on your lite line and fight for 15-20minutes to finesse it in, well - let's just say you are missing some kind of fun ( I know it still doesn't compare to a brownie in the park, but we have to amuse ourselves somehow)......

Now with that being said........until I gain TN residance and have crumbled cornbread in my buttermilk I will stay nuetral ....

Go Buckeyes

and Go Vols....stomp LSU

buckeyetrouter