My wife and I spent most of a week there last year. I ended up not even fishing while there (long story). But the place is great. I would love to go back and do some fishing. There's an open air bar/restaurant all the way at the southern end of the island called Santana's. Stop and get their lobster. They only have 2 things on the menu, lobster and fish, so the choices are minimal. Without asking, the owner will whip out her picture album and show you all the pictures of her with Johnny Depp. I guess he ate there pretty regularly while filming one of the Pirates of the Carribean movies. She's pretty proud of that. She also makes a mean rum punch.
My posts are worthless without pictures