I fish Forney Creek several times each spring, and have for the past six years. It nakes a nice day-trip from my weekend home near Bryson City. This last Saturday, I went for a few hours of fishing in the morning. I walked six-tenths of a mile up from Fontana Lake and began fishing a little below the confluence of Bear Creek at the bridge. There had been a cold snap the evening before, and with the high water I surmised that the fish would be a little sluggish. They were , but a few small rainbows came up and hit my yellow parachute. They were all holding in the slower water at the edges of the runs.
As you may recall, Bear Creek is a feeder stream that was poisoned a few years ago and re-stocked with Brook Trout. I believe that Bear Creek is still closed until a fishable population is re-established. Just as Bear Creek enters Forney, there is a small pool, the left half of which is covered by heavy rhododendron. I threw my dry into the pool, and a good trout darted out and nailed it. After a quick struggle, I landed the fish and realized I had caught a brookie - my first ever on Forney. The trout taped out against my rod at over 11 inches.
Looking at him, though, I noticed several unusual things. First, the trout's colors were mottled and not brilliant. If I had not been where I was, I'd have thought this fish came right out of the hatchery truck. Second, it was plump and well-fed. Most native brooks I have caught, and I have not caught many, are lean. The larger ones often have heads that are out-sized in relation to their bodies, perhaps because of a lack of nutrition. I have also observed that the better native fish often have purple coloring around and in their mouths. This fish displayed none of these characteristics. After the photo, I released the fish back into the pool.
I am doubly suspicious because of the large size of the fish. Most of the trout I have caught on Forney are small -- very small. My average is something around six inches. Of well over a hundred fish that I have caught or observed here, I have never landed a rainbow over 10 inches, and my largest all-time fish was a brown of 13 inches. Forney is a fairly infertile stream that just doesn't grow large fish. This fish has to be a transplant - but from where? My first instinct tell me that is is a hatchery fish that was stocked into another stream that feeds the lake, perhaps the Nantahala. This fish would need to enter the lake (in the case of the Nantahala that would mean surviving Wesser Falls), swim 15 miles to the Forney entrance, then make its way up through multiple 4 foot falls for 2/3's of a mile to have reached its holding place.
A second option is that the trout was stocked in Bear Creek. Getting here from Bear Creek would be easy for this fish -- just tumble down the 15 foot falls at the bottom of Bear. However, I don't believe mature 12 inch Brook trout from the hatchery were placed in Bear. Rather, I believe that the Park Service used small native brook trout taken from another nearby drainage. Therefore, it's hard for me to believe that this fish came down from Bear Creek.
Which leads to my question concerning this mystery. Where did this fish come from? Is it a stocker that made a miracle voyage to arrive in this portion of Forney? Did it come from Bear Creek? Or is it possibly a "real" native? Has anyone else caught a brook trout in the lower section of Forney Creek, or had a similar situation where they caught a fish that seemed out of place in its particular habitat? Thanks for any thoughts.