View Full Version : Clinch Management

03-24-2007, 07:12 AM
I wish I could attend the TWRA meeting Monday night, but expecting a new baby any day so probably won't be able to make it. Like the other members, I have also noted a slight decline in the number of quality fish on the Clinch over the last several years.

I recognize that, unfortunately, there will likely never be restrictive catch and release only/artificials only/significant size limit restrictions on the Clinch due to interests from the baitfishers and meatfishers. However, I always thought that placing restrictions on keeping the brown trout (catch and release only or slot limit or minimum 18") while leaving essentially no restrictions on the rainbows could be a viable compromise that could improve the quality of the fishery. I always wanted to ask TWRA about that, but looks like I'll miss my chance. Any thoughts? Perhaps something that could be brought up in the meeting.

03-24-2007, 11:11 AM
I did really well with a griffiths gnat about this time last year.

03-24-2007, 03:31 PM
Folks, my friend Jeremey (waterborn) just contacted me and asked if I was going to make it to this meeting Monday night. I can't (I have a good reason), but I urge those that can to be there. We (sportfisherman) need to start showing a strong presence at these meeting to show that we give a darn about the watersheds we enjoy. The squeaky wheel gets the grease. I, personally, think meatfisherman have been enjoying free range on this river for too long. It's time for a change.

03-24-2007, 06:45 PM
I agree RFowler, fisherman interested in the resource need to make their voice heard. Let me correct that, flyfisherman, need to have their voice heard. Like you said, the meat fisherman seems to have it made. I would love to attend but my work makes it all but impossible. TWRA needs to see an interest in improving things up there or they could stay the same.


Green Weenie
03-24-2007, 08:16 PM
When and where is this meeting going to be held? I don't have any irons in the fire for Monday night, so I should be able to attend.

03-25-2007, 08:07 PM

Flat Fly n
03-25-2007, 08:32 PM
Location 101 S. Hicks St., Clinton

It looks like on the map that it is just off Main St which runs parallel to 61

The time is 6:30 - 8PM

Just a personal footnote.
This issue is not about baitfishermen or flyfishermen. I could care less. It is about quality fishing. I believe the quality has been gone from the Clinch for a long time. I am not about imposing or restricting rights to LAND owners, but it is about common sense management.... too many people fishing and already overstressed resourse and limited money to continue to throw 3" fish by the truckload to try to fix. If the Clinch (as TWRA says) can grow fish, then why not grow and protect these fish until they reach an acceptable catch and keep size? Slot the river, or is it just the fact that folks manhood is questioned unless he comes home without his limit of 5" fish!

Flat Fly'n

03-25-2007, 11:40 PM
I have a few scars from this old discussion. There should have been some consideration for the people who would like to see a quality fishery on the Clinch a long time ago. I am not looking for "Catch and Release" regs either. Why not some common sense regs to allow some growth of the fish. Slot on the browns would be great. Maybe 1 over 18 and 1 under 12" ? You then have to have some enforcement on the river. The Clinch does not get enough natural reproduction to sustain (sp?) itself, so it will always be a "put and take" fishery, lets just finally add the word "grow" to the phrase "Put, grow and take!"
What I don't understand is the number of guys out there who feel it is a God given right to keep every trout they land, who don't think twice about throwing back every bass they catch. No offense to the bass, I grew up fishing for them and still enjoy them........ smallmouth in particular! I just don't enjoy the mindset.
It almost seems like this is a way of sticking it to the perceived elitest fly fisherman. That is a shame.
I am going to try to get there tomorrow night but I coach a U10 soccer team from 5:15 to 6:30pm. School nights are tough with kids as well.
Lame excuses, I know! I will be interested to hear a report if I don't make it. I will alot more to say afterward!

03-29-2007, 02:03 PM
Received a reply on my email letter to TWRA on Clinch Management Suggestions today.

"Thanks for your comments" Thats it! At least I know they received and read it even though it probably went to the Delete file.

SouthFork Skiff
04-01-2007, 04:51 AM
Lucky enough to get out Sat. day evening...and was lucky enough to land a 4+lb pound rainbow and the highlight of my fly fishing career...a 7+lb brown, hook jaw, all the things that get me goin!!!! So keep fishing, the management may not be the way we want it but some of the big ones are still there!!!

04-01-2007, 01:48 PM
Did you have a chance to get some shots of them, SFS? Many large trout reside in the Clinch. But, I think the crop of 14-20" fish is down. Certain areas are fairing well while others are suffering.

This brown is probably around 4lbs. It wasn't in the MI area.


SouthFork Skiff
04-01-2007, 07:46 PM
Unfortunately No...and boy was i kicking myself!!! Big time!!! I got the measurements of the fish and will have a replica made hopefully soon. He measured 25 and a quarter long and had a 15 inch girth!!!